How to choose a nursing home with Medicare Care Compare

How Medicare's nursing home star ratings work, what the abuse icon and Special Focus Facility sign mean, and how to use Florida's Watch List.

ยท 6 min read

Rollators parked along a hallway handrail in a care home

Photo by Carola68 on Pixabay

Choosing a nursing home often happens fast. A parent is in the hospital, the discharge planner hands you a list, and you have a day or two to pick a place for rehab or long-term care. Star ratings can help you narrow that list quickly, as long as you know what the stars measure and what they miss.

This guide walks through Medicare’s Care Compare website, how its five-star ratings are built, the two warning symbols every family should know (the abuse icon and the Special Focus Facility sign), and Florida’s own nursing home guide and Watch List. It ends with a simple plan for checking a nursing home before you commit.

Where to look

How Medicare’s star ratings work

Care Compare gives each nursing home an overall rating from 1 star (much below average) to 5 stars (much above average), plus three separate ratings. The details below come from CMS’s Five-Star Technical Users’ Guide (September 2026).

1. Health inspections

State inspectors visit each nursing home unannounced, about once a year on average, and spend several days checking things like resident rights, medications, skin care, food and the building. The inspection rating is based on the two most recent standard inspections, plus complaint inspections and infection-control inspections from the last three years. More serious and more widespread problems count for more points. This is the most important part of the overall rating.

2. Staffing

The staffing rating uses six measures drawn from payroll records the nursing home submits each quarter:

  • Total nursing hours per resident per day (registered nurses, licensed practical nurses and aides).
  • Registered nurse hours per resident per day.
  • Total nursing hours per resident on weekends.
  • Nursing staff turnover, registered nurse turnover, and administrator turnover over 12 months.

Staffing hours are adjusted for how sick the residents are. Florida also sets its own minimums in section 400.23: a weekly average of at least 3.6 hours of direct care per resident per day.

3. Quality measures

Quality measures come from resident assessments and Medicare claims. There are separate scores for long-stay residents (over 100 days) and short-stay rehab patients. Long-stay measures include falls with major injury, pressure ulcers, urinary tract infections, use of antipsychotic medicines, and hospital and emergency room visits. If your parent is going in for rehab, pay special attention to the short-stay score.

How the overall rating is built

CMS starts with the health inspection rating. It adds a star if staffing is 5 stars, or subtracts one if staffing is 1 star. It then does the same for quality measures. If the inspection rating is 1 star, the overall rating can rise by no more than one star. In other words, a home with a poor inspection record can’t hide behind good staffing numbers.

The abuse icon

Care Compare shows an abuse icon next to a nursing home that, in short:

  • Was cited for abuse that harmed a resident on its most recent standard inspection or on a complaint or infection-control inspection in the past 12 months, or
  • Was cited for abuse that could have harmed residents on recent inspections and again in the year or inspection cycle before.

A home with the icon has its inspection rating capped at 2 stars, so the best overall rating it can get is 4 stars. The icon comes off once the home no longer meets the criteria. Take the icon seriously: read the inspection report to see what happened and ask the administrator what changed.

Special Focus Facilities

CMS runs a Special Focus Facility (SFF) program for nursing homes with a history of serious quality problems. On Care Compare, an SFF shows a yellow warning sign instead of stars, and its other ratings show as “Not Available.”

According to CMS’s SFF list (October 2026), these homes are inspected about twice as often as others. To graduate, a home must meet CMS’s criteria on two standard inspections in a row, which takes about 12 months. CMS keeps graduates on the list for three years. It also publishes a list of SFF candidates: homes with records poor enough to be selected. Being a candidate isn’t a ruling, but it is a reason to look closely.

CMS’s guide also describes a new trophy icon for high-performing nursing homes. It is a positive sign, but check the inspection details anyway.

Florida’s own nursing home guide and Watch List

Florida law, section 400.191, still requires AHCA to publish a Nursing Home Guide every quarter and a Watch List. The Watch List includes nursing homes that met the criteria for a conditional license (meaning they weren’t in substantial compliance at an inspection) or that are operating under bankruptcy protection. Each entry shows the deficiency that put the home on the list and how many days it spent under a conditional license in the past 30 months. You can view the current Watch List on FloridaHealthFinder.

Florida also rates nursing homes on its own inspection results. Under AHCA’s methodology, the state looks at all inspection and complaint findings from the last 30 months and ranks each home only against others in its region. Five stars means the top 20% of the region and one star the bottom 20%. Besides an overall inspection rating, Florida scores areas such as quality of care, quality of life, nutrition and hydration, restraints and abuse, pressure ulcers, and decline and dignity. AHCA notes these are relative ranks, so a high rank doesn’t guarantee good care. Homes with a consistently strong record may earn Florida’s Gold Seal award.

Because Florida and Medicare use different data and methods, a home’s ratings may not match. When they disagree, read the actual inspection reports. Our guide on how to read a Florida AHCA inspection report can help.

A simple plan for choosing

  1. Make a short list of homes close to family, since frequent visits matter. Ask the hospital which homes have beds and accept your parent’s insurance or Medicaid. See places that accept Medicare or Medicaid.
  2. Check Care Compare for the overall rating, each of the three ratings, the abuse icon and the SFF sign.
  3. Check FloridaHealthFinder for the Watch List, state inspection ratings and any legal actions.
  4. Read the inspection reports, not just the stars. Look for repeat problems and anything involving harm.
  5. Visit, or send someone, at different times of day, including a weekend. Medicare’s guide to choosing a nursing home offers a checklist to bring.
  6. Ask about therapy if your parent is going for rehab: how many days a week, and who are the doctors?

Not sure a nursing home is the right level of care? Compare options in assisted living vs. nursing home vs. home care. If your parent is heading home instead, our sister site has a hospital discharge to home checklist.

If something goes wrong

Sources

Find senior living near family

Compare 1,700+ licensed assisted living facilities, nursing homes and adult day centers in Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach, with state inspection results.

Find a place