Assisted living vs. nursing home vs. home care in South Florida

How assisted living, nursing homes and home care differ in Florida: what each offers, how each is licensed, and what Medicare and Medicaid pay for.

ยท 6 min read

Three women of different generations walking hand in hand on a country path

Photo by silviarita on Pixabay

When a parent can no longer live safely on their own, families in South Florida usually end up weighing three options: an assisted living facility, a nursing home, or care brought into the home. Each one is licensed differently in Florida, offers a different level of care, and is paid for in different ways. Picking the wrong fit can mean a second move a few months later, or paying for more care than your parent needs.

This guide explains what each option is under Florida law, who it is a good fit for, and what Medicare and Medicaid will and will not pay for. It ends with questions to help you decide and local numbers to call for free help.

The three options at a glance

  • Assisted living facility (ALF): housing, meals and help with daily activities like bathing, dressing and medications, in a home-like setting. Not a medical facility.
  • Nursing home: 24-hour nursing care for people with serious medical needs, including short-term rehab after a hospital stay.
  • Home care: nurses, aides or companions who come to your parent’s own home, from a few hours a week to around the clock.

Assisted living facilities

Florida licenses assisted living facilities under Chapter 429, Part I of the Florida Statutes, and the Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA) inspects them. Under section 429.02, an ALF provides housing, meals and one or more “personal services” to adults who are not relatives of the owner. Personal services means hands-on help with or supervision of daily activities and taking medications. The law is clear that personal services do not include medical, nursing, dental or mental health treatment.

That matters when your parent’s health changes. Under section 429.26, an ALF generally may not admit or keep a resident who is bedridden or needs 24-hour nursing supervision. A resident who becomes bedridden can stay up to 7 days in a row (14 days in a facility with an extended congregate care license). Residents on hospice can stay if the facility, the hospice and a physician agree the needs can be met.

Some ALFs hold extra licenses that let them offer more care, such as extended congregate care, limited nursing services or limited mental health. Our guide to ECC, LNS and LMH specialty licenses explains each one. Florida has also created a new memory care services license (section 429.076). AHCA must adopt rules for it by June 1, 2027, after which ALFs that serve or advertise memory care will need it. See our memory care page for more.

ALFs range from small homes with a handful of residents to large buildings with hundreds of apartments. You can browse assisted living in South Florida or read about small assisted living homes and adult family care homes.

Nursing homes

Nursing homes are licensed under Chapter 400, Part II (“Nursing Homes”). Under section 400.021, a nursing home is a facility that provides nursing services, meaning care given by licensed nurses and the aides they supervise. This is the right setting for someone who needs skilled care every day, such as wound care, IV medications, tube feeding or close monitoring, or who needs a lot of physical help that an ALF can’t legally provide.

Florida sets minimum staffing levels in section 400.23. Each nursing home must provide, on a weekly average, at least 3.6 hours of direct care per resident per day. That includes at least 2.0 hours from certified nursing assistants and 1.0 hour from licensed nurses each day. AHCA must inspect each nursing home at least every 15 months.

Many people go to a nursing home for a short rehab stay after a hospital visit and then return home or move to assisted living. Others stay long term. Our guide on how to choose a nursing home with Medicare Care Compare shows how to check star ratings and inspections, and you can browse nursing homes by area.

Home care

Home care is regulated under Chapter 400, Part III (“Home Health Services”). There are a few kinds of providers:

  • Home health agencies must be licensed by AHCA under section 400.464. They employ the nurses, therapists and aides who come to the home.
  • Nurse registries must also be licensed, under section 400.506. They match families with nurses, aides and companions who work as independent contractors. The law says the registry may not supervise or train them, and must tell you so when you sign a contract.
  • Companions and homemakers help with company, meals, errands and housekeeping. Under section 400.462, they may not give hands-on personal care.

Home care can work well when the home is safe, someone can coordinate care, and the needs are predictable. It gets expensive when a person needs help around the clock. Our sister site, SoFlo Home Nurses, covers in-home care in depth, including home health agency vs. nurse registry vs. companion.

Who pays for what

Medicare

Medicare.gov says plainly that Medicare doesn’t pay for long-term care, also called custodial care. That includes the room, board and daily help in assisted living, and long-term stays in a nursing home.

Medicare does cover limited skilled nursing facility (SNF) care under Part A, short-term, after a medically necessary inpatient hospital stay of at least three days in a row. Time spent “under observation” or in the emergency room does not count toward the three days. You generally need to enter the SNF within about 30 days of leaving the hospital. For 2026, Original Medicare pays like this for each benefit period:

  • Days 1 to 20: $0 per day, after the $1,736 Part A deductible (if you haven’t already paid it for that hospital stay).
  • Days 21 to 100: $217 per day.
  • Day 101 and after: you pay all costs.

Medicare has posted 2027 figures of a $1,776 deductible and $222 per day for days 21 to 100. Medicare Advantage plans may have different rules and copays, so check with the plan.

For care at home, Medicare can cover home health services for people who are homebound and need part-time or intermittent skilled care, ordered by a doctor and given by a Medicare-certified agency. It does not cover 24-hour care at home, or personal care like bathing when that is the only care needed. Our sister site explains when Medicare covers home health care.

Medicaid

For people who qualify financially and medically, Florida’s Statewide Medicaid Managed Care Long-Term Care program lists assisted living, nursing facility care, and in-home services like personal care, homemaker and adult day health care among its covered services. Not every facility accepts Medicaid, so ask early. See our guide to Florida Medicaid long-term care or browse places that accept Medicaid.

Paying privately

Many families pay out of pocket at first, sometimes with help from long-term care insurance or VA benefits. Prices vary widely by setting, room type and care level, so get written rates from each place you consider.

How to decide

  1. Start with the medical needs. Does your parent need a nurse every day, or mostly help with daily tasks and reminders? Ask their doctor directly which setting fits.
  2. Think about safety at night. Wandering, falls or confusion after dark often tip the balance toward a facility.
  3. Be honest about the caregiver. If one family member is doing most of the work, burnout is real. Our sister site has a guide to caregiver burnout and respite care.
  4. Check the money. Know what Medicare will cover, whether Medicaid is possible, and how long savings will last.
  5. Look at the record. Every facility profile on our site shows its AHCA license and inspection history (or Medicare star ratings for nursing homes). Search all licensed places or start with your county: Miami-Dade, Broward or Palm Beach.

Free local help

Your local Aging and Disability Resource Center can explain options and screen for programs at no cost:

  • Miami-Dade: Alliance for Aging Elder Helpline, 305-670-4357
  • Broward: ADRC of Broward County, 954-745-9779
  • Palm Beach: Area Agency on Aging Palm Beach/Treasure Coast, 1-866-684-5885
  • Statewide Elder Helpline: 1-800-963-5337

SoFlo Senior Living is a free directory, not a placement agency. We don’t take referral fees, and we list every licensed place A to Z.

Sources

Find senior living near family

Compare 1,700+ licensed assisted living facilities, nursing homes and adult day centers in Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach, with state inspection results.

Find a place